Despite his death taking place in Newark, New Jersey at the hands of the British, John Willcocks is buried in in the Deserted Village of Feltville in Berkeley Heights, Union County, New Jersey. His family was somewhat prominent in the area, enough to have a family cemetery that also holds a related family called Badgley.
There are estimated to be 24 graves in the Willcocks Badgley Cemetery. Three of them are Revolutionary War Patriots. Cousin Joseph Badgley died in December 1785, after suffering war-related wounds. John’s brother William Willcocks died in 1800 after serving as judge advocate in Chatham NJ, for Revolutionary court martials during the war.
And given the source of the photo in today’s cover art, it appears that the cemetery has a geocaching site somewhere on the grounds. It’s part of the part of the Watchung Reservation History Trail of geocaches. So if geocaching AND history are your hobbies, you’re in luck!
When I lived in northern New Jersey, as I mentioned a couple of days ago, I was just a few blocks from the Passaic River. But the river wasn’t quite as large there as it was where Washington’s army crossed it.
There is a modern-day bridge at that crossing spot, and the (misspelled) sign in today’s cover art marks that spot, on the east side of the river. On the west side of the river is River Drive, which (surprise!) runs along the river for a ways. There’s a second marker there.
But wait! There’s more!
Maybe a hundred yards away, in Armory Park on Main Street, there’s a third sign, which is an exact replica of an earlier sign at the same spot that had been placed in 1932. The interesting thing is that the two signs on the west side of the bridge are worded almost identically, though one refers to “Blanchard House” and the other refers to “The Tap House.” However, both signs are referring to the same tavern, which is no longer extant but is the home of Saints Peter and Paul Church. Having said that, there are several markers around the church, marking the Blanchard House’s location, a monument to George Washington, and a couple of significant grave markers.
And—this I found weird-but-interesting—near the second bridge marker there’s a Burger King. And in the parking lot there’s a memorial to Lord Stirling, who was with the Continental Army during the crossing and set up the headquarters at Blanchard House. We’ll hear more from Stirling around Christmas time, shortly before this show ends.
Calling it “The Battle of Fort Lee” feels like a misnomer, largely because it was more like “The Continentals Get The Hell Out of Town Before the British Arrive.”
As noted in yesterday’s episode, General Cornwallis actually began moving on the fort the night before. His troops struck camp and crossed the Husdon River, landing in Closter, a hamlet otherwise so insignificant that I actually lived in Bergen County for several years (not far from where a lot of The Sopranos exteriors were filmed) and still had to look up its location. It’s only ten miles (as the crow flies) from where I lived!
Anyway.
About 4000 troops had landed at Closter, and since nobody knew they were there, they managed to make their way up the Palisades without anyone interfering. Not long after dawn, an American soldier on patrol spotted them and raced back to the fort to raise the alarm.
George Washington had already begun plans to evacuate the fort and begin moving the army across New Jersey, but this news meant that whatever plans were already underway had to be abandoned, and everybody just dropped everything and left. So much for The Battle of Fort Lee.
Things were looking pretty bleak for the Continental Army, but the escape meant that the army was able to survive and score a couple of decisive wins just a few weeks later at Trenton and Princeton.
Nathanael Greene recommended defending Fort Washington, but once that fell, the evacuation of Fort Lee was pretty much a foregone conclusion.
George Washington determined, not unreasonably, that Fort Lee was mostly useful in conjunction with Fort Washington: being approximately across the Hudson River from one another, they could harass any British movement up or down the river. With one fort gone, there was no point in sticking around for the other one.
And once again, in getting out when he did, George “The Fox” Washington managed to escape capture by the British once again.
America, it seems, has always had an awkward relationship with the lottery.
Back in 1762, the Pennsylvania legislature barred anyone from running lotteries, levying fines and diverting that money to the poor. In short, they felt that a lottery was a regressive tax on the lower-income people that could lead to the corruption of young people.
Other colonies did the same, and for much the same reason. However, despite the laws, lotteries were still popular and managed to continue somehow, especially on a smaller scale, where they were used to finance things like churches, universities–oh, and the French and Indian War.
Lotteries could also be used to dispose of property: if someone dies and the heirs need to sell off the estate, community members might buy tickets to win the house that they otherwise couldn’t afford. (Unfortunately, this could also apply to slaves; however a slave could conceivably win their own freedom. It was rare but it did happen.)
Federal anti-lottery laws killed most lotteries by 1895, and after that the first state-sanctioned lottery was held in 1964 in New Hampshire. Not long after that, other states fell back into the lottery game as a means of raising funds, in defiance of those federal laws, which weren’t repealed until sometime in the 1790s.
I’m not a regular lottery player; I’m the kind who waits until there’s a gigantic jackpot and then I’ll buy a single Quick Pick ticket just for the fun of it. My one objection to a lottery (besides the usual “it’s a tax on people who can’t do math” bit) is that it’s often sold as a means of raising revenue to fund schools. The problem is, in most cases lottery income to states isn’t encumbered for educational purposes; it still goes into the General Fund and offsets other money previously earmarked for education. As far as I know, Florida is the only state that actually marks lottery income in its state budget as an addition to existing money, but it’s still a remarkably small percentage of the total amount of money taken in.
At any rate, it’s interesting that the arguments that we hear against the lottery today are more or less the same ones they were using over 250 years ago.
Robert Trimble was well-respected by his judicial peers, at least after he died. They said some very kind things about him them.
But I got a little curious to know whether he participated in any especially notable cases while he was on the Supreme Court. I couldn’t find any, but I did find it interesting that he generally voted with Chief Justice John Marshall almost every time. However, there was one case in which Marshall dissented from the majority opinion, choosing to write his own opioin “assenting” to the judgment in part, and dissenting in another part. In addition, Trimble wrote the majority opinion in the case.
The case was Ogden v. Saunders, and it determined the scope of a bankruptcy law in relation to a clause in the Constitution. In short, Saunders was a Kentucky citizen who demanded payment on a contract. Ogden was a Louisiana citizen who lived in New York and had declared bankruptcy in that state. He claimed that, under the New York bankrupcy law, he was no longer bound to the contract. The main issue was whether the New York law violated the Obligation of Contracts Clause of the Constitution. In short, did Congress have exclusive power to pass bankruptcy laws?
The Court’s response was that the Constitution’s clause prevented states from passing only laws that affected existing signed contracts; the states couldn’t pass laws that affected future contracts, because those contracts were bound by existing laws already. Short version: Ogden won the case because the New York law did not violate the Constitution.
What I found interesting about this is the way it echoed—yet also ran against—a decision from just a few years earlier: Gibbons v. Ogden (different Ogden, go figure), involving conflicting laws between Congress and New York, this time regarding steamboat regulation. In that one, the Court sided with Gibbons, stating that in matters of interstate commerce, the Federal law holds the greater power.
If the Battle of Fort Washington wasn’t the biggest loss for the American side of the entire war, it was definitely the worst so far.
We noted yesterday that General William Howe sent in a notice advising Colonel Robert Magaw to surrender the fort, or everyone in it would be killed. Magaw was defiant, sying the Patriots would defend the fort to the “last extremity.” Luckily for Magaw and company, Howe didn’t follow all they way through on his threat.
The main fighting began around 7:00 AM, when British and Hessian troops attacked from two directions, largely from the south. One of them, however, was a feint to draw attention from the other, which aimed directly at the fort and more specifically at the guns which had damaged British ships in the past.
By midday, more troops had arrived and easily dispersed the Americans waiting for them. From the north, a Hessian group met nearly no resistance as they moved up toward the high ground. Finally they were med by rifemen near the Post Road, who were especially good at guerilla-style warfare, and they managed to turn the Hessians back.
Of special note is John Corbin and his wife. Corbin was in charge of a cannon atop a ridge located on present-day Bennett Park. John was killed by a Hessian assault, so his wife Margaret, who was nearby at the time, took his place at the cannon and fired at the invasion until she was wounded repeatedly, making her the first known woman combatant in the Revolution. She did survive the battle but never fully recovered from her wounds, permanently unable to use her left arm.
In the end, the fort fell by 4:00 PM. 59 Americans had been killed, 96 were wounded and 2837 were captured, Magaw among the captives. The British and Hessians suffered 84 killed and 274 wounded. Because the British treated Revolutionary War prisoners rather poorly, about three-quarters of the prisoners died; only about 800 survived and were released in a prisoner exchange. Magaw was required to remain in New York for the duration as part of his parole, and eventually returned to Pennsylvania to resume his law practice.
Visitors to Bennett Park will see a commemorative plaque there (the one used for yesterday’s cover art), plus stones in the ground marking the locations where the walls of the fort once stood. A short walk from there is Fort Washington Park, on the banks of the Hudson, and the home of the Little Red Lighthouse, made notable by the 1942 children’s book The Little Red Lighthouse and The Great Gray Bridge.
General Howe sent Lieutenant Colonel James Patterson to Fort Washington under a flag of truce, with a message: give up the fort now, or everyone dies.
Colonel Robert Magaw’s reply, in not-so-many words, was to buzz off.
Now, neither Magaw nor Patterson were of special note except for this one exchange. Magaw was a lawyer from Pennsylvania, who joined the militia shortly before the war broke out, but except for this battle was relatively undistinguished.
Patterson was also not of special note, as it happens. I started to wonder whether the New Jersey city of Paterson (one t) was named after James Patterson (two t’s), but it was not. It was named after William Paterson (also one t), a signer of the Constitution and the second governor of New Jersey.
So really: this was a day where two relative nobodies managed to shine on through history.
A quick note about today’s artwork. I was hoping to find a portrait of Ben Franklin that was a little different from the ones we usually see. Perhaps the most popular portait of him is the one by Joseph Duplessis from around 1785, and is the basis of his image on the $100 bill.
There’s another one that’s gotten more popular in recent years. It was painted by David Martin and depicts Franklin in a white wig and a blue coat with elaborate gold trim and buttons, reading some document. That dates back to 1767. Weirdly, I don’t much like it; it feels a little contrived and even has a bit of an AI feel to it. That one is supposed to be on display in the White House at present, go figure. (Remember please: this is entirely my opinion. You’re free to like it, or not, as much as you want.)
The one in today’s art is from 1789 and is by Charles Willson Peale, who managed to capture a lot of the Founding Fathers on canvas. It’s a little quirkier than most portraits of that time, with the glasses obscuring the eyes a little bit, the fact that Franklin is facing the viewer’s left rather than the right (or directly at the viewer), and the pool of light on the upper portion of the image. (Some have suggested that the light is coming from the thunderbolt outside…I don’t know about that one.)
There’s often symbolism in these portraits, and in this case we get the distant lightning bolt, an allusion to his “lightning is electricity” experiment from 1752. There’s also a small lightning rod in his hand and another on the table in front of him.
This painting was commissioned by the American Philosophical Society, of which Franklin was a member, but they rejected it on completion. Oddly, the Society already had a portrait: the one by David Martin, which Peale himself had copied at one time. Perhaps they wanted something more up-to-date; it’s unclear. After the rejection, nobody knows where it was for the next sixty years, until it was given to the Historical Society of Pennsylvania. Its condition suggested that a buyer had been found for it, and it had been on display somewhere. The HSP still has the portrait if you’re curious to see it in person.
While Nathanael Greene’s advice on this particular occasion wasn’t the best, we shouldn’t extrapolate that into deciding that Greene was bad at his job.
Far from it, in fact. Greene was regarded by peers and historians as second only to Washington in his skills as a general. It was once said of Greene that he was a master strategist who could see patterns where others couldn’t, and could often get soldiers to do things that others could not. And chances are, the only reason Greene isn’t better known is because he died in 1786 following sunstroke, rather than living to a ripe old age and becoming a prominent politician, or dying in battle. Greene was 43 years old at his untimely death.
In the late 1770s Greene moved to the Southern theater of the war, where he served up several American victories, and a couple of instances where the Americans technically lost but the British losses were substantially larger (which sounds like a common theme around here). As a result of his actions throughout the south, there are numerous municipalities and counties across the US that are named for him, not to mention several Naval ships.