Tag: New York History

  • The Fall of Fort Washington–November 16, 1776

    Cover art for November 16, 1776: "A View of the Attack Against Fort Washington". Contemporaneous drawing by British officer Thomas Davies. via New York Public Library Digital Library.

    If the Battle of Fort Washington wasn’t the biggest loss for the American side of the entire war, it was definitely the worst so far.

    We noted yesterday that General William Howe sent in a notice advising Colonel Robert Magaw to surrender the fort, or everyone in it would be killed. Magaw was defiant, sying the Patriots would defend the fort to the “last extremity.” Luckily for Magaw and company, Howe didn’t follow all they way through on his threat.

    The main fighting began around 7:00 AM, when British and Hessian troops attacked from two directions, largely from the south. One of them, however, was a feint to draw attention from the other, which aimed directly at the fort and more specifically at the guns which had damaged British ships in the past.

    By midday, more troops had arrived and easily dispersed the Americans waiting for them. From the north, a Hessian group met nearly no resistance as they moved up toward the high ground. Finally they were med by rifemen near the Post Road, who were especially good at guerilla-style warfare, and they managed to turn the Hessians back.

    Of special note is John Corbin and his wife. Corbin was in charge of a cannon atop a ridge located on present-day Bennett Park. John was killed by a Hessian assault, so his wife Margaret, who was nearby at the time, took his place at the cannon and fired at the invasion until she was wounded repeatedly, making her the first known woman combatant in the Revolution. She did survive the battle but never fully recovered from her wounds, permanently unable to use her left arm.

    In the end, the fort fell by 4:00 PM. 59 Americans had been killed, 96 were wounded and 2837 were captured, Magaw among the captives. The British and Hessians suffered 84 killed and 274 wounded. Because the British treated Revolutionary War prisoners rather poorly, about three-quarters of the prisoners died; only about 800 survived and were released in a prisoner exchange. Magaw was required to remain in New York for the duration as part of his parole, and eventually returned to Pennsylvania to resume his law practice.

    Visitors to Bennett Park will see a commemorative plaque there (the one used for yesterday’s cover art), plus stones in the ground marking the locations where the walls of the fort once stood. A short walk from there is Fort Washington Park, on the banks of the Hudson, and the home of the Little Red Lighthouse, made notable by the 1942 children’s book The Little Red Lighthouse and The Great Gray Bridge.

  • One Last Chance To Surrender–November 15, 1776

    Cover art for November 15, 1776: A tablet commemorating the location of Fort Washington in modern-day Bennett Park, New York City. Photo taken by the team Equipe C'est N'est Pas Une Pipe as part of the Commons: Wikis Take Manhattan project. Licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported License.

    General Howe sent Lieutenant Colonel James Patterson to Fort Washington under a flag of truce, with a message: give up the fort now, or everyone dies.

    Colonel Robert Magaw’s reply, in not-so-many words, was to buzz off.

    Now, neither Magaw nor Patterson were of special note except for this one exchange. Magaw was a lawyer from Pennsylvania, who joined the militia shortly before the war broke out, but except for this battle was relatively undistinguished.

    Patterson was also not of special note, as it happens. I started to wonder whether the New Jersey city of Paterson (one t) was named after James Patterson (two t’s), but it was not. It was named after William Paterson (also one t), a signer of the Constitution and the second governor of New Jersey.

    So really: this was a day where two relative nobodies managed to shine on through history.

  • Stalled Decisions–November 13, 1776

    Cover art for November 13, 1776: Statue of Nathanael Greene at the Rhode Island State House. Photo by Wikipedia user Kenneth C. Zirkel.

    While Nathanael Greene’s advice on this particular occasion wasn’t the best, we shouldn’t extrapolate that into deciding that Greene was bad at his job.

    Far from it, in fact. Greene was regarded by peers and historians as second only to Washington in his skills as a general. It was once said of Greene that he was a master strategist who could see patterns where others couldn’t, and could often get soldiers to do things that others could not. And chances are, the only reason Greene isn’t better known is because he died in 1786 following sunstroke, rather than living to a ripe old age and becoming a prominent politician, or dying in battle. Greene was 43 years old at his untimely death.

    In the late 1770s Greene moved to the Southern theater of the war, where he served up several American victories, and a couple of instances where the Americans technically lost but the British losses were substantially larger (which sounds like a common theme around here). As a result of his actions throughout the south, there are numerous municipalities and counties across the US that are named for him, not to mention several Naval ships.

  • The Less-Famous Crossing–November 12, 1776

    Cover art for November 12, 1776

    George Washington took about two thousand troops across two major rivers as a tactical move. Both times he was headed into New Jersey. But only one of those crossings gets much attention, which we’ll talk about in the last week of this show.

    That would be his crossing the Delaware River from Pennsylvania into Trenton. But there was also a crossing of the Hudson River, from New York into Fort Lee. So how come the Delaware gets so much attention and the Hudson doesn’t?

    First off, you have that famous painting. That’s got to be a big piece of it. There are no images that I could find depicting the crossing of the Hudson; in fact the image I used in today’s cover art is the British troops making their crossing on November 19th. But the other thing is, crossing the Delaware was a tactical move as part of a sneak attack on Trenton that turned into a huge victory for the Continental Army. (oops, spoiler alert.) Crossing the Hudson was a tactical retreat. Running away isn’t going to look very heroic.

    (Fun Fact: that 1851 painting of Washington’s crossing is actually one of three. The original painting was part of an art collection in a German museum, and it was unfortunately destroyed in a British bombing raid in 1942, during World War II. The other two, made around the same time, are slightly different in size. One is at the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York and the other was auctioned off in 2022 and is now in private hands.)

    This is the stuff I think about sometimes.

  • A Move Southward–November 7, 1776

    Cover art for November 7, 1776: Contemporary map of northern Manhattan. Fort Washington is at bottom left; Kingsbridge is just above the "w" in "Southward". via Boston Public Library Digital Collection.

    It was pretty well-known by this point that General Howe’s objective was to occupy New York and then move northward through the Hudson Valley.

    General Washington had issued a discretionary order to General Nathanael Greene to abandon the fort and remove its garrison, which then numbered about 3,000 men, to New Jersey.

    Colonel Robert Magaw, the acting commander of the fort, refused to abandon it, believing his troops would be able to defend it from the British. This stubbornness pretty much cost him his ability to participate in the rest of the war, as he was captured when the British finally moved in.

    Magaw was paroled later on but not permitted to leave Manhattan until the war was over. And Britain held Manhattan the entire time, so Magaw was basically out of a job when it came to the Continental Army, and may explain why there are no locations named after him. The site where his home in New Carlisle, PA is now a coffee shop/café and there is a plaque nearby marking the café as a stop on the Patriot’s Path.

  • Howe Moves, And A Church Mystery–November 5, 1776

    Cover art for November 5, 1776: The second Grace Church in Rye, NY. Artist and specific date of creation unknown. via Christ's Church archives.

    I do enjoy it when coincidental stories come together.

    We did mention a couple of days ago that this was a period of relative lawlessness in the downstate New York area, and the murder of Reverend Ephraim Avery is a definitive example of this.

    Avery’s murder was never solved, but apparently it was the stuff of much gossip and speculation. I actually learned about this incident while looking for something else and I stumbled over the story of the dedication and Evensong event which marks the 250th anniversary of the Reverend Avery’s death.

    If you’re in the area, the memorial dedication will be followed by a catered dinner in the Parish Hall and a presentation by a local historian discussing Avery’s live and legacy. Everything starts at 6:00 tonight. The suggested donation is $20/person or $50/family.

  • Demont Gives Up Fort Washington–November 2, 1776

    Cover art for November 2, 1776: William Demont('s ghost), as depicted in the Scooby-Doo Show, Episode 116, "The Spirits of '76". Image nicked from Scoobypedia.

    William Demont was a traitor in much the same way that Benedict Arnold was, but Washington chose to keep this story a little quieter, largely for morale reasons.

    So how does he make it into an episode of Scooby Doo?

    It’s worth remembering that as we approached the Bicentennial, America was absolutely immersed in the whole Spirit of ’76 and showed great interest in that era. (Frankly it’s sort of what we were hoping would happen again when we first came up with this show. Anyway.) The American Colonial Era was a constant focus in media, from Philadelphia turning into a major tourist location to Red, White and Blue everything everywhere. So the fact that a Scooby Doo episode offered up a history lesson didn’t really seem out of place. Here’s what happened in the story:

    Mystery, Inc. visits Washington DC but the weather turns rainy and they duck into the Splitsonian Institute. Oddly, the museum has practically no visitors and a guard explains that it’s empty because it’s haunted. Then the guard reminds them that it’s nearly closing time.

    Shaggy sees a tableau with a sign in front of it: “Traitors of American History”, with wax figures of Benedict Arnold, William Demont and Major André. (Demont is the only one wearing civilian clothes, even though he was in the Continental Army.) As everyone moves on, Scooby sniffs at Demont’s statue but is pushed away by its leg.

    Hijinks ensue, etc etc and the gang eventually reveal that Major André isn’t a ghost but an accomplice of the other two men. William Demont is unmasked and turns out to be Mr. Wilit, an employee who actually sleeps in the museum. And Benedict Arnold winds up actually being one of the guards. The three men replaced the wax dummies with themselves; their plan was to use a drill to cut through the basement wall to the US Mint next door, so they could steal the money therein. What they didn’t know is that the money they were going to steal had no treasury seal, no serial numbers and no signature printed on them yet, so they were worthless.

    See? History lesson and a little bit of civics/economics to boot.

    Also, for what it’s worth, John Stephenson voiced all three of the “ghost” characters and two others besides in this episode. However, Frank Welker (who also voices Fred) provided the voice for Mr. Wilit, the man in the Demont mask.

  • Retreating North–October 31, 1776

    Cover art for October 31, 1776: "The Battle of White Plains," originally designed as a commemorative postage stamp by Edmund F. Ward in 1926. Ward finished the larger oil painting in 1932. via White Plains Public Library.

    When George Washington retreated his men under cover of darkness from White Plains to North Castle, he expected General Howe to follow.

    Howe didn’t take the bait.

    So the two men sat there for a couple of days, each hoping to draw the other one out. The fact was, Howe wasn’t all that interested in pursuing Washington’s army, so he turned his attention elsewhere in the end. Stay tuned; we’ll get there in a couple of days.

    This was a good news/bad news situation for the Continental Army. Good, because they coulld take a breather from near-constant fighting since mid-August; bad because Howe’s troops weren’t stretching themselves thin with occupying territory they’d won.

  • The Morning After–October 29, 1776

    Cover art for October 29, 1776: detail of a wood engraving by Benson John Lossing of Chatteron's Hill, 1851. via the Huntington Library in San Marino, CA.

    The Battle of White Plains was long, and it was complicated, and once things settled down, both armies needed a little time to regroup and figure out what happened.

    It was clear that, despite the relative gains for the British, the casualties were comparable (at worst) to those of the Americans. General Howe’s aim in not pursuing matters further was to await the arrival of reinforcements. Could he have have gotten the job done without them? Maybe; the Americans were outnumbered but they were still formidable fighters despite their relative lack of training.

    George Washington, on the other hand, was trying to re-organize in order to safely retreat and fight another day. But things in Downstate New York aren’t quite over yet, and we’ll be returning here in a couple of days. Stay tuned.

  • Battle of White Plains–October 28, 1776

    Cover art for October 28, 1776: detail of a 19th century painting of Johann Rall, painted by George Whiting Flagg, based on an earlier sketch by John Trumbull. via the Old Barracks Museum in Trenton, NJ.

    The Battle of White Plains, like so many others we’ve described, was technically a victory for the British, but the overall cost and/or final result leaves everyone wondering whether the win was worth it.

    As we’ve noted repeatedly, the objective of all this activity in New York was for the British to take control of the Hudson Valley and the river all the way up to Canada, thus cutting New England off from the rest of the colonies and, in theory, making it impossible for Connecticut, Rhode Island, New Hampshire and Massachusetts to get any supplies without Britain’s permission. (Remember, Vermont and Maine weren’t states yet.)

    And while the British won in Brooklyn, and then Manhattan, and again today at the Battle of White Plains, George Washington’s movements just kept moving the goalposts just a little further away. Washington probably should ahve moved west to get away from the British and regroup, but he chose instead to move north, essentially forcing the British to chase him again rather than just move in and do whatever they wanted to do.

    As we move into the last couple of months of this podcast, we will return to this activity a few times before we’re done. So, stick around!